AgentMoves Team
March 1, 2026
Chelsea Peitz has been one of the most influential voices in real estate social media for years, and her core message has never been more relevant: most agents are broadcasting when they should be conversing. The agents who succeed on social media aren’t the ones with the most polished content, they’re the ones who use content as a conversation starter and then actually have the conversations. Here’s the framework.
The Problem With a Posting-Only Strategy
Most real estate agents approach social media with a content calendar mindset: post three times per week, use the right hashtags, and hope leads come in. This approach treats social media like a billboard, passive, one-directional, and impossible to measure.
Chelsea Peitz’s insight is simple but profound: social media platforms are designed to facilitate connection, not consumption. The algorithm rewards accounts that generate conversation, not just views. And the clients who convert aren’t the ones who passively scroll past your market updates, they’re the ones who commented on your post, replied to your story, or sent you a DM.
The shift is from:
- Broadcasting → Conversing
- Polished performance → Authentic presence
- Follower count → Connection quality
- Content volume → Conversation volume
The Conversations Framework in Practice
Peitz’s framework centers on using content as a bridge to direct, one-on-one conversation. Here’s how to apply it as a real estate agent:
Step 1: Create content that invites response Instead of statements, use questions. Instead of announcements, ask for opinions. “What would you do?” and “Have you experienced this?” posts generate comments. Comments are conversations. Conversations lead to relationships.
Examples:
- “Interest rates dropped again this week. Does this change your timeline to buy? Drop your answer below.”
- “I walked through a home today with zero closet space. Deal breaker or not a big deal? 👇”
- “The neighborhood I’m seeing the most multiple-offer situations right now is… [city]. Curious if others are seeing the same thing.”
Step 2: Move the conversation to direct message When someone comments on your post, don’t just like it, respond with a question that invites them to continue the conversation in DMs. “That’s a great point, are you currently in the market?” is a natural bridge.
Step 3: Treat DMs like phone calls A DM conversation is not a casual exchange, it’s a real business conversation happening in text form. Ask questions, listen, provide value. Do not jump to “let me show you some listings” before you understand their situation.
Step 4: Move offline when the time is right The goal of social media isn’t to close transactions in DMs. It’s to build enough trust and rapport that the person wants to meet with you. When the conversation is warm, extend a natural invitation: “I’d love to grab coffee and talk through your options, are you available this week?”
What This Looks Like Week to Week
A conversations-focused social media week for a real estate agent might look like:
- Monday: Post a question-based market stat, respond to all comments within 60 minutes
- Tuesday: Reply to 10 stories from people in your sphere (reactions start conversations)
- Wednesday: Reach out to 5 DMs from the past week to check in and continue conversations
- Thursday: Share a behind-the-scenes Story with a poll or question sticker
- Friday: Respond to all DMs and comments from the week
This approach takes roughly the same time as a traditional content schedule, but it produces dramatically more human connection, which is what actually drives real estate referrals and conversions.
AgentMoves supports a conversations-based social strategy by handling the content creation and scheduling side so you can spend your social media time on actual conversations. See how it works, start with a free Marketing Visibility Audit at AgentMoves.
Share this article